Being Good at Your Job Doesn't Mean You Feel Like You Belong: the quiet isolation of being competent, different, and sometimes misunderstood.

 



A few weeks ago, I wrote about my tendency to minimize certain experiences, particularly as the only Black man in my workplace. I talked about the mental energy involved in questioning my own reactions, giving others the benefit of the doubt, and sometimes dismissing my own feelings in the process. Now, I am beginning to realize there is another layer to this experience that I have not fully explored.

What happens when you are good at your job, genuinely enjoy what you do, and still feel isolated in the workplace?

Let me start by making something clear: I like my job. I believe in the mission of the organization, I know my field, I learn quickly, and I am confident in the value I bring. I have accomplished a great deal in a relatively brief period, including taking on responsibilities that extend beyond my actual job description.

My struggle is not with the work. My struggle, I think, is with everything surrounding the work.

Being Liked Is Not the Same as Belonging

I believe my colleagues like me. People smile when they see me, we laugh, we exchange pleasantries, and I have had some genuinely good conversations. However, there is a difference between being liked and truly belonging.

Someone recently made a comment that everyone should have a "best friend" at work. Someone to have lunch with, talk to, and share the day with. I thought about that statement for a while, because, I do not have that person. Not even close. Now, I am not suggesting that work needs to be a social club or that my colleagues are obligated to become my friends. I have a life outside of work, and I am perfectly capable of enjoying my own company. But the comment made me realize something: there is a particular kind of loneliness that comes from being surrounded by people who are friendly toward you, but who do not necessarily know you.

Some of that may be age, some may be cultural differences, and some may simply be that people are still trying to figure out who I am and where I fit. Perhaps that is part of the problem.

I do not fit neatly into boxes!

I have lived in different countries, worked in different industries, experienced different cultures, and developed perspectives that do not always align with what people expect when they look at me. I am a first generation American and I am not deliberately mysterious. I simply do not believe that a person's identity, experiences, or abilities can be neatly summarized by a label. But workplaces, like people, often rely on labels to make sense of one another. When someone does not fit an expected category, I wonder whether people sometimes struggle to figure out how to engage with them.

The Exhaustion of Performing

This is the part I am still trying to understand about myself. I often feel as though I am performing. Not in the sense that I am being dishonest or pretending to be someone else, but rather, I find myself adjusting how I communicate, how I respond, how much of my personality I reveal, and even how I express frustration. I want people to feel comfortable around me, but sometimes I wonder how much energy I spend making others comfortable while neglecting my own comfort.

Am I being too direct? Should I soften that statement? Is my enthusiasm being interpreted as arrogance? Is my confidence being mistaken for something else? Should I explain my perspective again, or should I just let it go?

These are not necessarily questions unique to Black professionals. Many people navigate them. But as I discussed in my previous article, being the only Black man in a workplace can add another dimension to those calculations because I do not always know whether an interaction is influenced by race, age, culture, personality, or simply different communication styles. And I do not want to assume that I know.

But uncertainty about the cause does not eliminate the impact. Sometimes, by the end of the day, I am tired from things that have absolutely nothing to do with the actual work I was hired to do.

The Invisible Work of High Achievers

There is another interesting dynamic I have noticed, and that is, when you are competent, independent, and consistently deliver results, people sometimes assume you do not need much attention. You become the person who can figure things out, the person who will handle it, the person who does not need much supervision; and to a certain extent, which is a compliment!

I have a supervisor who supports me and advocates for me, and I genuinely appreciate that. But I have also noticed that because I generally manage things well, it can be easy for my own need for engagement, feedback, and recognition to get overlooked. I suspect this happens to many high achievers.

Being low maintenance does not mean being without needs.

We still want to know that our work matters, we still want someone to recognize the effort behind the results, we still want to have meaningful conversations about what we are accomplishing and where we are going, and sometimes, we simply want someone to ask how we are doing rather than assume everything is fine because the work keeps getting done.

I sometimes wonder how many people in my workplace could accurately describe what I actually do? Not my title, or the general purpose of my department, but what I actually do.

And how many would know about the contributions I make outside my formal responsibilities?

This is not about needing applause for every accomplishment. I am far enough along in my career that I do not need constant validation. But there is a difference between seeking applause and wanting your contributions to be understood.

Competence should not make someone invisible.

When Communication Becomes the Hardest Part of the Job

I recently had a particularly difficult day at work, and interestingly, the difficulty had very little to do with my actual responsibilities and everything to do with communication.

I have spent years in leadership, education, and management, and one thing I have learned is that a person's position does not automatically make them an effective communicator.

Communication is a skill, and like any skill, it requires awareness, practice, and a willingness to learn. People have different styles. Some are direct, some are diplomatic, some are collaborative, and some communicate in ways that may unintentionally dismiss or diminish others. I can work with different styles, and I have done so throughout my career. But there are moments when the way something is communicated becomes more frustrating than the actual issue being discussed.

Particularly when you feel that your knowledge, experience, or perspective is being dismissed before it has even been considered. I sometimes share information because I genuinely believe it could help someone, improve a process, or provide useful context, and when that information is met with what feels like dismissal or a scoff, I find myself withdrawing a little.

I can handle disagreement and I welcome thoughtful disagreement; but there is a difference between disagreeing with someone's ideas and making them feel that their contribution was not worth considering. When these interactions accumulate, they begin to affect how willing you are to participate, and that should concern any organization, because the moment people stop sharing ideas is often the moment an organization begins losing value it does not even realize it has.

I Am Still Figuring This Out

I do not want this article to be mistaken for a complaint about my employer or my colleagues because I work with good people. I believe in what we do. I am proud of the work I accomplish, and I have no intention of allowing difficult moments to overshadow the meaningful parts of my job. I also recognize that I have a role to play in building relationships, communicating my needs, and helping others understand me.

Perhaps I need to be more intentional about that, perhaps I need to stop assuming that people will recognize contributions simply because the work is getting done, and perhaps I need to be more willing to tell my supervisor when I need engagement rather than waiting for someone to notice. I need to accept that not every workplace will provide the same sense of connection I have experienced elsewhere. I am also learning that acknowledging these feelings does not make me ungrateful, difficult, or a victim because sometimes we experience things that genuinely hurt or isolate us. We should be able to acknowledge that without having to defend our strength or competence.

·         I can love my job and still have difficult days.

·         I can respect my colleagues and still question how we communicate.

·         I can be confident in my abilities and still want to feel seen.

·         And I can be independent without wanting to be isolated.

In my previous article, I wrote about how minimizing my experiences did not make them smaller. It simply made them harder to explain, and I think I am beginning to understand something else.

There is a difference between being strong enough to stand alone and wanting to stand alone.

I know I can stand alone and I have done it many times throughout my life; but I am beginning to question why being capable of standing alone so often becomes the expectation.

Perhaps that is the conversation we need to have about workplace belonging and not whether everyone has a best friend at work. Whether everyone has a place where they can contribute, be understood, and occasionally put down the weight of having to prove that they belong.

Dr Flavius Akerele III

PS, this was written raw and from the heart, so I really do not care about the typos and grammar.

#WorkplaceBelonging #BlackProfessionals #Leadership #WorkplaceCulture #InvisibleLabor

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The truth about “black on black crime’ by Dr Flavius Akerele III

The importance of handwriting

The Leadership Lessons We Forgot: Practical Insights from More Than 20 Years in Leadership, Teaching, and Consulting